Mystery Shopper Checklist and Report Template

A practical mystery shopper checklist for email and web enquiries, a simple scoring template, and how to turn the results into improvements.

By the Mystery Shopper AI editorial team

Published November 13, 2026

Short answer: a good mystery shopper checklist for enquiries covers six things: how fast the first real reply came, whether every question was answered, whether there was a clear next step, how personal the reply was, how specific (prices, dates, details), and how well it was written. Score each one the same way every time and write one action per test.

This checklist is for testing your own business's replies to customer enquiries by email or web form. (Related keywords people search for this: "secret shopper checklist", "mystery shopper report template".)

The checklist

1. Speed (the clock)

  • When was the enquiry sent? (date and time)
  • When did the first human reply arrive? (auto-replies don't count)
  • Was it within your target time?
  • If outside working hours, did an auto-reply say when to expect an answer?

2. Answered every question

  • List each question the enquiry asked.
  • Was each one answered clearly?
  • If something couldn't be answered, did they say when it would be?

3. Clear next step

  • Is there a booking link, proposed time, quote, or a specific question back?
  • Is it easy to act on immediately?

4. Personal, not canned

  • Uses the customer's name.
  • Refers to their actual situation (dates, group size, product).
  • Doesn't read like a generic template pasted without changes.

5. Specific

  • Gives prices or a range where asked.
  • Gives dates or availability where asked.
  • Avoids vague phrases like "it depends, please call".

6. Writing

  • Clear and polite.
  • No spelling or grammar errors.
  • Right length: complete but not a wall of text.
  • Includes the business name and contact details.

A simple report template

Field Entry
Business / location
Channel email / web form
Scenario e.g. price and availability for a group of 12
Sent date, time
First human reply date, time
Reply time
Speed (0–30)
Answered every question (0–25)
Next step (0–15)
Personal (0–10)
Specific (0–10)
Writing (0–10)
Total (0–100)
What went well
One thing to change

The weights above put speed and answering the question first, because a slow or incomplete answer is the most common reason an enquiry goes elsewhere. Adjust them to your business, but keep them the same from one test to the next so results are comparable.

Example: scoring one reply

Suppose the test enquiry asked a hotel for a double room on two dates, the direct-booking rate and whether early check-in is possible. The reply arrived after 3 hours, gave the rate and availability, ignored the early check-in question, used the guest's name, and ended with "let us know if you have questions".

  • Speed: 24/30 (within four hours)
  • Answered every question: 15/25 (one of three questions missed)
  • Next step: 5/15 (no booking link or offer to hold the room)
  • Personal: 8/10
  • Specific: 9/10
  • Writing: 9/10
  • Total: 70/100. One action: add a booking link and a "shall I hold the room?" line to the reservations template.

(An illustrative example of how the scorecard works.)

How to score fairly

  • Write the scenario's questions down before sending, so you score against what was actually asked.
  • Use the same scorecard every time.
  • Have the same person score, or two people who agree on examples first.
  • Score the reply, not the person. A weak reply often points to a missing price list or template.

Turning results into improvements

If the problem is… Try…
Slow replies a named inbox owner each day; notifications on new enquiries
Unanswered questions a short answer sheet for the 10 most common questions
No next step a closing line with a booking link or two time options
Canned replies templates with a first line that must be personalised
Vague answers published price ranges staff are allowed to share

Speed deserves attention: writing in Harvard Business Review in 2011, Oldroyd, McElheran and Elkington argued that most companies are not responding to online leads nearly fast enough. See our guide on speed to lead.

Let the checklist run itself

Mystery Shopper AI applies this scorecard automatically to tests on your own business: it writes and sends a realistic enquiry at a random time, and when you paste the reply, it times it and scores all six criteria out of 100, with three tips and a stronger example reply. Planning regular tests? Read how to set up a mystery shopping program.

FAQ

What should a mystery shopper report include?

The scenario, timestamps, a score per criterion, a total, what went well and one concrete action.

How long should the checklist be?

Short enough to fill in for every test. Six criteria with a few checks each is plenty for enquiries.

Can I use this for phone calls?

Mostly, yes: replace the speed check with how many rings before answer and whether the call was answered at all.

How fast does your team really reply?

An AI mystery shopper emails your business a realistic enquiry at a random time, then times and scores the reply.

Test your response

Sources

Explore more guides